58 Former Judges, Attorneys Criticize Special Prosecutor in Capital Murder Case

A Prince William County Circuit Court judge appointed Fairfax County Commonwealth's Attorney Raymond Morrogh in October to prosecute the Justin Wolfe murder-for-hire retrial.

Nearly five dozen former judges, prosecutors and other attorneys signed a letter this week criticizing the appointment of the Fairfax County Commonwealth's Attorney as special prosecutor in a decade-old capital murder case, and his decision to retry the defendant.

A Prince William County Circuit Court judge in September appointed Raymond Morrogh to prosecute the case during the retrial of Justin Wolfe, a Chantilly High School graduate, who was convicted over a decade ago for ordering the murder of his drug supplier, Daniel Petrole Jr., of Centreville. Wolfe's conviction was thrown out by a federal judge last year, and the vacation of his sentence was subsequently upheld by an appeals court. The courts also criticized Prince William County prosecutors for witholding evidence in the case. 

The letter, which was dated Oct. 24, was addressed to Judge Mary Grace O'Brien and signed by 58 members of the legal community, including a former assistant commonwealth's attorney from Fairfax County. The signers said that Prince William County's top prosecutor, Paul Ebert, had an undue influence selecting Morrogh. Ebert was criticized by the courts for his work on the case and forced to recuse himself. 

"As former judges, prosecutors, and other members of the legal community, we are deeply disturbed by the misconduct of prosecutors that led a jury to sentence Justin Wolfe to death," the letter reads. "We are equally troubled by the haste with which the newly appointed special prosecutor, Fairfax Commonwealth's Attorney Raymond Morrogh, has decided to re-try Mr. Wolfe."

In a September court appearance, Morrogh said that he believed Wolfe was "was absolutely involved in this murder. He planned it and caused it to occur." In the same hearing, O'Brien, the judge, said Morrogh probably would have been her selection even if Ebert had not suggested it, due to his past experience and geographic proximity. 

The letter sharply criticized Morrogh's decision to retry Wolfe, and suggested that he was influenced by his connections with Ebert, who has endorsed his campaign for commonwealth's attorney

"Unfortunately, less than 24 hours after his appointment, Mr. Morrogh announced his intention to retry Wolfe. This suggests a hurried decision in which the special prosecutor did not carefully examine the evidence to reach an independent conclusion about the case, but instead relied on the earlier deliberation of the Prince William County prosecutors—prosecutors who were responsible for the misconduct and errors in judgement that left Mr. Wolfe on death row for more than a decade," the letter reads.

Pre-trial motions in the Wolfe case continue next week. 

Read more:

Wolfe Trial Pushed to January

Raymond Morrogh Appointed Special Prosecutor in Justin Wolfe Case

Triggerman: Death Row Inmate is Innocent

All Previous Coverage of the Justin Wolfe Case on Patch

Kevin November 12, 2012 at 06:14 AM
Sorry, Justin is as guilty as they come. I don't think he should be executed but he should be kept in jail another 15 years or so. Witnesses recant all the time, and that was only part of the evidence that convicted this kid. He is very fortunate to be getting a retrial but I think he will be convicted a second time.
Innocence Victum December 14, 2012 at 12:34 PM
Kevin you have no idea what your talking about. This guy worked with me. I knew him. There is no evidence in this case. This court uses stereotypes and false testimony on everyone who pleads not guilty and will go prosecute you with no evidence. They are trying to protect their job. Unfortunately they habititually bare false witness and in this case the murderer already confessed and the court prosecutors are angry that they lied and had this guy on death row for nothing. This goes on in a lot of casee in this county. I am a first class victim of this court and the facts can not be changed. These people knew what they where doing and still went forward. Now they are trying to protect there license to practice law. This is just like the Mike Nython case with the Duke Lacrosse team. Prosecutorial misconduct at its finest.
Michael Josef Basl January 01, 2013 at 08:21 AM
Marion Barry January 03, 2013 at 08:53 PM
He is guilty as hell
Rosanne Bushnell June 09, 2013 at 01:27 AM
There is ustice and there old fashioned justice where the outcome is predetermined. If this happens to Mr. Wolfe, it can happen to you, to me, to your Dad. Think about this man getting a fair trial that is all we ask you to do. We are not interested in opinions. Only solidly fair law practice and an unbiased judge. Rosanne D. Bushnell


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something