Virginia Ignores Marijuana Reform Proposals

Virginia treats marijuana possession more harshly than many other states, handing down years-long prison sentences to people arrested with small amounts of the substance.

By Charles Couch and Amir Vera
Capital News Service

RICHMOND – After months of an undercover investigation in 2008, a Yorktown County police officer finally had enough evidence to charge Brandon Gomez, then 18, with intent to distribute marijuana.

“I had actually been just basically the middleman,” Gomez said, describing himself as an intermediary between a dealer and users in marijuana sales.
During the investigation, the undercover officer bought four ounces of marijuana.

After Gomez spent a few nights in jail, the officer offered him a deal: If he turned in his dealer and buyers, the felony charges would be reduced to misdemeanors. Gomez reluctantly agreed, and spent the next six months betraying the people who trusted him most.

“The way I saw it, that was almost worse than me having to stay in jail – having had to deal with that for months on end,” Gomez said. “I lost friends because I tried to be honest with my close friends about what I had done about the guy I was middle-manning for.”


In 2009, Jordan McNeish was 20-years-old and living in Albemarle County. His neighbors had complained several times about noise from his apartment.

When he answered the door one night, thinking it was a friend, it turned out to be a police officer responding to another noise violation. The officer saw a beer in McNeish’s hand. Knowing McNeish was underage, the officer stepped into the apartment to investigate.

“He pushed past me, came into my house, threw his flashlight around and found a bag of what was marijuana,” McNeish said. The officer sent his partner to get a search warrant. When they came back, they ended up finding two ounces of marijuana.

McNeish was convicted of intent to distribute marijuana—a more serious offense than possession—and sentenced to five and a half years in jail. He got out after six months for good behavior and now has three years of supervised probation.

“It was determined to be an ‘intent to distribute’ charge not because of packaging or any other evidence other than quantity. Half an ounce is automatic intent to distribute in Virginia,” McNeish said.


The cases involving Gomez and McNeish illustrate how severely Virginia deals with marijuana possession. Both men felt their punishments outweighed their crimes. And both face the long-term consequences of being convicted criminals.

Virginia treats marijuana possession more harshly than many other states, handing down years-long sentences to people arrested with small amounts of the substance. Neighboring states have decriminalized marijuana or approved it for medicinal uses, but Virginia legislators this year hardly gave serious consideration to such ideas.

An exception was Delegate Onzlee Ware, D-Roanoke, who proposed House Bill 485. It sought to allow individuals convicted of marijuana possession to petition for expungement, and have the charges cleared, after five years.

“I believe in second chances; I believe a person can mess up. And once they’ve atoned themselves and pay restitutions and rehabilitated themselves, they ought to be restored back whole – meaning it shouldn’t show on their record,” Ware said.

The bill died in a subcommittee of the House Courts of Justice Committee.
Former Delegate Harvey Morgan, a Republican from Gloucester, is familiar with that panel. Before retiring in 2011, he tried for five years to relax Virginia’s marijuana laws.

At first, Morgan, a pharmacist, introduced bills to expunge criminal records of marijuana charges. Then he altered his strategy and tried decriminalizing marijuana – changing the $500 criminal fine for simple possession to a $500 civil charge and eliminating the threat of prison time.

Morgan’s efforts also foundered in the House Courts of Justice Committee.

“The criminal subcommittee consisted primarily of attorneys who have been prosecutors, and they have the mindset that it (marijuana possession) should not be decriminalized,” Morgan said. “If it went to any other committee in the General Assembly, it would stand a lot better chance.”

As a result, Ware said, Virginia remains very strict concerning marijuana laws.

“Virginia is in the minority on this. Other states usually just automatically expunge your records after five or 10 years, especially on nonviolent crimes and misdemeanors. But Virginia, once again, holds the distinction of being in the very small minority. I know we have the most restricted expungement statute in the country,” Ware said.

Ed McCann, executive director of the Virginia chapter National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws, says Virginia is typical of the South.

“I know states with harsher laws,” McCann said. “As far as Southern states go, we’re probably in the middle.”

He said Western states generally have the most liberal marijuana laws. New England is lenient, too. Connecticut is about to become the 17th state to allow marijuana for medical reasons. Under the Connecticut law, doctors could prescribe the substance specifically to patients with debilitating diseases such as cancer or AIDS.

Midwestern states are still pretty strict, McCann said. The mid-Atlantic states vary in how they treat marijuana users.

North Carolina has decriminalized the substance. So if you’re arrested there with a marijuana cigarette, you might get the equivalent of a parking ticket.

If you smoke marijuana in Maryland as treatment for glaucoma, judges might let you off. Maryland legislators are debating proposals to legalize marijuana for medical uses. 

But if you’re arrested smoking marijuana in Virginia, even for medical reasons, you could face hard time – 30 days in a state prison on a first offense or as much as 10 years on a subsequent offense.
McCann says that’s unfair.

“There are a lot of pot smokers in Virginia, you know. We’re all regular people, and we need to be respected and not arrested anymore,” McCann said.

NORML’s goal is to legalize the use of marijuana by adults. The group supports having a regulated system allowing adults to buy marijuana for recreational, medical and spiritual use.

“In other words, just like alcohol – with restrictions and regulations that are approved by the community so that people know where marijuana’s being sold, they know who’s selling it and when it’s being done,” McCann said. “They can collect the taxes and they can make the regulation so that kids aren’t being allowed to access it.”

An initiative to regulate marijuana like alcohol will be on the ballot in Colorado in November. The state of Washington is planning a similar referendum.

Those elections may determine how the rest of the nation will view reforming marijuana laws, McNeish said.

“If that passes, I think that other states will probably find this goal is more realistic,” McNeish said. “But if that fails and gets pushed back another two years, I think it could be seven or 10 years before Virginia could do anything like that, because Virginia’s not going to be the first state to legalize it – that’s for sure.”

Before Virginia’s laws on marijuana can change, Ware and Morgan said, the mindset in the General Assembly must change – starting with the House Courts of Justice Committee.

“It never gets out of committee … The people that run it are prosecutors, and they don’t believe giving any break to anybody. Once you’re a criminal, they don’t believe in giving breaks. It’s just a difference in philosophy, so they kill the bill,” Ware said.

In the meantime, people like McNeish and Gomez must live with the consequences of being caught with marijuana. Their criminal records will haunt them the rest of their lives, making it hard to find work or housing and even vote.

Gomez is a senior at Virginia Commonwealth University. He’d like to join the Navy SEALs. But because of his record, that might not be possible.
“They passed this new mandate that said that no one, because they’re overfilled right now, with any sort of drug charges is allowed in,” Gomez said. “I know I have potential. I’ve always wanted to join the military, but now I may not be able to join.”

McNeish, who works doing auto restoration, said he has had issues applying for housing.

“I’ve been lucky with jobs,” McNeish said. “But I have noticed that it’s been extremely hard for me to find a place. Lots of applications ask if you have any criminal record; other applications only ask for felonies.”

Dwayne & Maryanne Moyers May 09, 2012 at 05:00 PM
Virginia is tough on marijuana possession? Really? After arresting countless people for marijuana possession I would strongly disagree. Not once did I see a defendant go to jail. Under 18.2-251 a typical sentence involved staying out of trouble for 12 months. If no criminal offenses occur within 12 months the charge is dismissed. If a subsequent arrest occurred violating the terms of dismissal, the most punishment I've witnessed delivered by a judge was 10 days (with half of these days to serve suspended). Typically fines were between $250 to $50. Depending on the defendants criminal record the fine was usually on the low side. After an arresting officer takes the time to confiscate the plant material, packages the marijuana for lab testing, completes a criminal report, fingerprints the offender, transports the evidence to the laboratory (Fairfax County), files the certificate of analysis, and the Commonwealth typically uses the talents of the examiners at the Virginia Division of Forensic Science to verify the substance, the fines collected come nowhere near the cost of the offense. Judges do not take marijuana possession serious. Even if they wanted to imprison offenders there is no space in jails for them to serve jail time. The state of Virginia should treat it like the safeguards in place to keep cigarettes directly out of the hands of minors. Legalize it for adults while collecting heavy tax revenues. I'm not a fan of marijuana and I do not use it,
Dwayne & Maryanne Moyers May 09, 2012 at 05:02 PM
But the court system cannot take the offense seriously. So it's time to consider legalizing it. I have no doubt legalization would reduce street crime. Marijuana legalization across the country would reduce illegal traffic and violence on a national scale on our southern borders. It is everywhere already, and accessible to anyone. I don't think legalizing it would make much of a difference regarding addiction problems.
Kevin_Hunt May 09, 2012 at 05:02 PM
Since all hemp is considered a schedule I drug by the DEA, we must conclude that our founding fathers were marijuana growers and dealers.
MoonshineDelight May 09, 2012 at 09:01 PM
I believe the officer when he says most defendents aren't jailed, but the true cost to society isn't the court and corrections proceedings. The "record" is the real crime. Because joe six pack was busted smokin a doobie at the rock show he now has a permanent drug conviction, and is castigated down the societal ladder with likes of depraved junky fiend. Despite his marketable skill/trade that associated stigma will prohibit him from ever obtaining gainful employment and force him into becoming another ward of the state.
Jimmy J. May 10, 2012 at 01:24 PM
The only way to make changes is to educate people on marijuana and it's potential to generate income for the state via taxes and also assist those who would medically benefit from the use of the drug. Virginia would not be inventing the wheel here, there are plenty of states that have laws and regulations in place that VA would be able to implement and allow the use of marijuana for medical purposes. I would be for an all out legalization of the drug in a tightly regulated method, but that may not ever happen in my lifetime. I would hope that Virginians would educate themselves and also vote in folks who can buck the status quo and not merely rubber stamp past philosophical ideas.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »